25 Old-Fashioned Amish Recipes – Insanely Good

Amish cook recipes

These simple

old-fashioned Amish recipes are simple but spectacular

. Amish

dishes are mostly made from homegrown staples, but are full of flavor.

Amish Country Pasta Casserole with Ground Beef

Consisting of noodles, potatoes and meats, Amish meals are very plentiful and plentiful


Milk and eggs are also a big part of their diet, so the dishes are super rich and creamy.

The best recipes are passed down from generation to generation, so they’re available for us to try today.

You’ll see plenty of creamy casseroles and baked goods on this list, so prepare your stomachs for a heavy meal!

From macaroni salad to sugar crackers, here are 25 amazing Amish recipes for you to try.

Macaroni salad with mayonnaise and vegetables

1. Amish macaroni salad

Let’s get the ball rolling with a guaranteed party punch!

Amish macaroni salad is a ridiculously creamy dish of elbow macaroni, hard-boiled eggs, pickles, red peppers, and onions.

Tying them all together is a sweet and sour dressing of miraculous whip, mustard, sugar and vinegar


Take it to your next shared meal, and it will surely surprise your friends


2. Amish Breakfast Casserole

Start your day with a hearty breakfast casserole. Loaded with hash browns, bacon and cheeses, this casserole is the stuff of legends.

This is not your typical casserole, folks. In addition to the usual ingredients, it features three different cheeses: cheddar, cottage and swiss.

To say it’s rich and cheesy is an understatement


Broccoli salad with cauliflower and vegetables

3. Amish broccoli salad

Broccoli and cauliflower don’t sound like something kids will enjoy


Mix them with bacon and cheddar cheese and soak them in a rich, creamy dressing, and I’m pretty sure they’ll ask for more


From color to flavor to texture, I give this salad a 12/10. I suggest you duplicate the batch, as it disappears quickly.

4. Amish Friendship Bread

This bread has an interesting name, a history and a delicious taste


Amish friendship

bread is a cake-like bread made from a starter that is passed from person to person,

just like chain mail


But instead of being 7 years of bad luck, you’ll get delicious bread


Don’t worry, you won’t have to wait for someone to give you a starter to make this recipe. Whey is key!

5. Amish Yumasetti Casserole

What a funny name, right? Yumasetti is a traditional Amish casserole made from noodles and beef.

See also  Pre-cooking chicken for the week = winning at meal planning

There are many variations of the casserole, some with tomato sauce, others topped with cheese


For this recipe, you’ll combine ground beef, noodles, sour cream, and a combination of chicken soup cream and mushroom soup cream


That said, expect an ultra-rich and creamy casserole!

6. Amish

White Bread

With this homemade Amish white bread, your sandwiches have never tasted better


This bread is super soft, fluffy and just plain delicious


A recipe makes two breads, which is perfect if you have people


Serve as a side dish to roast beef for a spectacular meal


7. Amish Baked Chicken Amish

baked chicken is so crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside


It’s so good that you’ll easily trick people into thinking it took your hours

to do it.

They are baked, not fried, so there is no need to stand for minutes in front of the hot stove to make it


Just wait while the oven works its magic!

8. Pennsylvania Dutch Chicken

and Meatballs Pennsylvania Dutch chicken and dumplings

are a vintage recipe that is definitely a gatekeeper. Chopped roast chicken


thick, square dumplings swim in a creamy, flavorful broth


Made even more filling with potatoes, carrots and sweet peas, this dish is a complete meal on its own


It seems like a complicated dish, considering that you will have to make the meatballs from scratch.

But in reality, it is not! In fact, the dish is prepared in just under an hour.

9. Amish Potato Salad

Amish Potato Salad has the perfect combination of sweet, spicy, creamy and savory


Since potatoes and hard-boiled eggs are the stars of the dish, it’s a hearty side that pairs well with any meat


It’s partyworthy, sure, but it’s also pretty easy to do any day of the week.

One recipe makes a huge batch, but you’ll be surprised how quickly it disappears!

10. Amish Whey Cookies

These whey cookies are wonderfully rich and flaky


You’ll think they take hours to do, but they’re actually done in just 30 minutes thanks to a simple folding technique


This quick bread is perfect for breakfast combined with sausage sauce or spread with butter and honey. Either way, it’s fantastic.

See also  Cafe Rio Sweet Pork Recipe (Slow Cooker) - Six Sisters' Stuff

11. Amish Chicken Corn Casserole

This chicken and corn casserole has a Ritz cookie crumb topping. How amazing does that sound? It’s comfort food at its best.

The chicken and corn kernels are topped with a creamy, buttery sauce. That alone is already a winner.

But it’s the flattened Ritz cookies on top that take you to a whole new level of delight


12. Amish Onion Burgers

These onion burgers are simple, but they sure hit the spot


The contrasts between sweet and spicy, tender and crisp create incredible fireworks

in my mouth.

You can dip them in ketchup or sauce, but personally, I love it with sour cream


I can’t get enough, and no, I don’t regret my onion breath!

13. Amish Ground Beef and Cabbage Skillet

This colorful and inexpensive skillet will be your new favorite. The combination of ground beef and cabbage makes it a hearty and tasty dish.

The best part? This recipe is gathered in a single pan. It’s easy to make, easy to clean, but impossible to resist!

14. Amish cabbage and potato casserole

Ground beef, potatoes and cabbage join forces to make a delicious casserole


There are also plenty of cheese slices on top, ensuring maximum magnificence

. Sure, it

takes over an hour to bake, but it’s definitely worth the wait


15. Amish Baked Oatmeal

Elevate your regular oatmeal to an unforgettable dish!

Rolled oatmeal, maple syrup, cinnamon, and vanilla are baked to perfection, giving you a great meal in the morning.

I love how these squares are able to maintain their shape! It’s like eating a giant oatmeal cookie.

Even those who hate oatmeal will have no problem devouring this dish!

16. Amish Baked Beans

Looking for delicious comfort food to warm up on a cold, rainy night? Look no further than these Amish baked beans.

The soft, tender beans swim in a sweet, salty, smoked sauce. It takes a while to cook, but preparation couldn’t be easier.

17. Amish Pancakes

These pancakes are outrageously light and fluffy!

They’re great for breakfast and lunch, but I also don’t mind devouring them for dinner. They’re that good.

No matter the

mixture, no matter the topping, these pancakes are a sure win


Whoopie Pies

18. Whoopie Pie

Warning: These sandwiches

are highly addictive. Two

See also  Pumpkin Slow Cooker Steel Cut Oats - The Clean Eating Couple

soft, chewy chocolate sandwiches are filled with a sweet, fluffy filling


If you can’t decide between a cake and a cookie, here’s your answer


19. Amish Cake

is a basic cake: soft, fluffy and moist. What sets it apart is the ridiculously buttery brown sugar and nut topping.

Trust me, you’ll want that second serving



. Amish Apple Fritter Bread This

apple fritter bread is the epitome of fall desserts


The combination of soft, crunchy apples and brown sugar and cinnamon is absolutely to die for


Finished with a sweet vanilla frosting, this bread is the best way to start the day


21. Amish Apple Goodie

It’s definitely a treat! The aroma will only make you drool.

This crunchy

apple recipe has a crispy, buttery oatmeal streusel coating that will blow you away at the first bite.

22. Amish Apple Dumplings

If you want to put a new spin on apple pie, this recipe is calling your name

. These

apple dumplings are incredibly delicious


Sweet, crispy apples are covered with a buttery dough and baked to perfection


Drizzled with sugar syrup and cinnamon on top, these dumplings will blow your taste buds.

Amish Caramel Corn


. Amish Corn Candy

The Amish may not watch movies, but they make popcorn


This caramel corn has a beautiful combination of sweet and savory, and the crunchiness is undeniable


Serve this on your next game night or water it to family and friends. They will love you for it!

24. Amish Oatmeal

There was a shortage of nuts during the Civil War, so instead of making nut cakes, people made oatmeal cakes.

They are amazing, and much cheaper, to boot!

The filling

is a combination of brown sugar, butter, rolled oatmeal and milk


Once baked, the filling becomes wonderfully sticky. The sweet and buttery taste is also impossible to resist.

Sugar Cookies

25. Amish Sugar Cookies

Let’s end this list with a bang! These Amish sugar cookies are definitely the bomb.

They are incredibly soft that almost melt in the mouth. It is impossible to stop at one.

Also, look at how delicate they look! So delicate, so attractive.

They are beautiful as they are, but you can also animate them however you want. Sprinkling, colored sugar, lemon glaze, you name it!

Amish Recipes

Related Articles

Back to top button